Receiving the Voice
Walt Whitman: A Gay Life, by Gary Schmidgall (Dutton)
Just in case there was any doubt: Walt Whitman was gay.
In a clear attempt to free himself and scholarship from the near cliché that Whitman’s sexuality was not “gay” as we know it, Gary Schmidgall, author, most notably, of The Stranger Wilde: Interpreting Oscar, proves to readers not only the undoubted sexual identity of Walt Whitman but also that Whitman played an instrumental role in the creation of the modern gay identity as we know it today.
Schmidgall places special emphasis on the growth of Whitman’s unique and singular voice, one that could utter soul-truths with the subtle vocalise of a bel canto diva. This voice, Schmidgall argues, is one distinctly and purposefully gay. The author convincingly demonstrates how Whitman’s exposure to opera taught him to use his own voice as a means of empowerment and visibility: “What was for Whitman the ‘deepest’ lesson of opera? And what, by extension, is the deepest lesson in Whitman’s poetry? The answers may be the same; they may both have to do, simply, with receiving the voice.”
Schmidgall criticizes the generations of critics who lauded Whitman with the most sweeping of titles, from Poet of Democracy to Poet of the Earth, but overlooked the one most apropos, Poet of the Body (primarily the body of a man). Surprisingly, schools still exhibit ambivalence about teaching Whitman. When you get beyond poems like “O Captain, My Captain” and “I Hear America Singing,” what’s he really saying? Who’s he supporting? He’s certainly not a graying Establishment poet. He, like the late Allen Ginsberg, would want to be known for his strong-chested howl at cool conformity. Many teachers are concerned that their students might just pick up on it. I had a shocking run-in a couple of years ago with a high school advisor who felt that a student essay on Whitman was not appropriate for a school-funded journal. “Too racy, too fringe” was his remark. Whitman had indeed done his job; he’d elicited a strong, albeit negative, reaction from the Ivory Tower.
My earliest experience of interpreting (rather innocently, I must say) autobiography from Walt Whitman’s work came sitting on the floor of my bedroom — I guess at about eleven years old — cutting the previously unread pages in a 1900 edition of Leaves of Grass that I had liberated from a neighbor’s tag sale. Strangely, the uncut pages (mainly, the ones in Calamus) proved the best and also the most revealing, both of my pre-adolescent desires and those of Whitman himself. As a gay child, I read the symbols as ciphers of a secret comradeship. He liked other boys, too, I said to myself, breathing a sigh of relief. The spiritual brotherhood of a poem like “We Two Boys Together Clinging,” linked with the poem’s blatant physicality, illuminated the closeness that I felt toward other boys. To the child who searched for role-models and certainties, the gay father-figure of Walt Whitman helped to banish much unnecessary teenage guilt and shame.
Whether or not Whitman himself was comfortable with the masses knowing about his private pleasures is a question Schmidgall addresses throughout the book. He manages to find some rather interesting materials with which to construct a (sexual) profile of Whitman, in Horace Logo Traubel’s nine volumes of transcriptions of conversations with Whitman, during the years 1888 to 1892, entitled With Walt Whitman in Camden. Schmidgall quotes extensively from the last two volumes which were only published last year by William Bentley. Schmidgall makes a point of showing that Whitman was very careful in revealing himself to others. Certainly, the nature of the poet’s sexuality is clear to readers, but Whitman was much more reticent in person. Homosexuality was veiled by terms like “Greek pleasures” and other Classicalizing phrases.
However, what most comes to the fore, in Schmidgall and elsewhere, is how much indeed Whitman detested being classified in any way by others. His was a rebellious artistic temperament if ever there was one. Letting his work speak for itself (with the help of not a little ingenious self-promotion) was Whitman’s preferred method of aesthetic “communication.” The ‘solitary singer’ had a song to sing that others might, if they so pleased, comment on. But as soon as he finished his aria, the divo was silent.
The portrait Schmidgall paints of Whitman is that of a man willing to reinvent himself in a costumier’s assortment of guises and poses, reflected in the extant photographs we have of him. Whitman, as gay poet, never quite sits still long enough to let the classifying eye place him in a pre-fab compartment. Whitman creates, with each chosen word, the compartment into which he would like to be placed. And with each poem the compartment changes. Whitman is hardly a simple nineteenth-century mid-Atlantic poet. He is, at turns, cosmopolitan, tragic, foreign, passionate. He manages to work himself free of religious systems that bind individuals to lives of mere imitation and emulation. Life was for Whitman, as Schmidgall points out, a realm of countless possibilities, of multiplicities and ambiguities, and wonder.
Recently, I gave a friend of mine leaving New York a copy of Whitman’s poems. (I must admit it was a hasty buy at about six p.m. in a Penn Station bookshop). Traveling to see him on the train, I opened the book and began reading “Song of Myself.” There could not have been a more appropriate place to read a volume of Whitman. No hunky, baritone-voiced motormen, I thought to myself, but just enough in the way of diversity (hundreds of faces, builds, languages) to appease old Walt. As Whitman himself wrote in a letter to Emerson: “Every day I go among the people of Manhattan Island, Brooklyn, and the other cities, and among the young men, to discover the spirit of them, and to refresh myself.”
What struck me most in the text, however, were the lines praising friendship and a comradeship of love: joined hands, enfolded arms, gaze fixed steadily upon gaze. Here was a friendship that was not afraid to be itself, that thought nothing of what others would think. A gay Whitman, I thought, in touch with the body of another, for sure — but first, at home in his own soul, exploratory in spirit, peering wildly into the soul of another. “Each singing what belongs to him or her and to no one else, . . . Singing with open mouths their strong, melodious song.”
Schmidgall’s biography, in its portrayal of Whitman’s sexuality, quite successfully sketches a multi-layered picture. Always interesting and quirky, Schmidgall shows that the writing of biography is always the unique testimony of the biographer. In the case of Walt Whitman: A Gay Life, two gay comrades, Whitman and Schmidgall, have given themselves to us wisely, and for that they both deserve a brava.