Brand Voice / Copywriting

Reviews

Book reviews and criticism by Christopher Voigt, writer, editor and creative director.

Navigating the Absurd

Albert Camus: A Life, by Olivier Todd, translated from the French by Benjamin Ivry (Knopf)

Who cannot recall the words, “Today Maman died, or maybe yesterday, I don’t know. I got a telegram from the home, ‘Mother deceased, burial tomorrow, sincerely yours.’ I can’t tell, maybe it was yesterday …”? Nearly all of us have in a college French, philosophy, or literature class encountered these words. What did they mean to us? Probably in the high-speed of freshman or sophomore year not much. Looking back on those first lines of Albert Camus’ novel L’Étranger (translated “The Stranger” or “The Outsider”) we might be struck by their freshness and their uniqueness in a pantheon of overachieving first lines.

Camus knew when he wrote those lines that they were the beginning of a great novel, the likes of which no one had ever seen before. There was, then, no need to inflate, nor any need to add filigree to the emotions of Camus’ protagonist, or anti-protagonist, Meursault. Like his character, Camus believed in a basic honesty. Unlike his character, Camus as a man had to live in a world where attitudes and ways of living were prescribed. He perceived this as a form of madness but chose to criticize through his work and art. Whereas Meursault was at the liberty of his author – his creator – Camus was free in both mind and spirit. He recognized that even with the exterior constraints of government regimes and social prejudices, the pressure to live a human life was on him as an individual. In his journalism, his plays, and his novels, Camus showed human life for what it was – a less than perfect situation that demanded the dedication and scrutiny of both the heart and the mind.

For Camus, human life neither offered a clear solution, nor did it at any time boast of one. In its over four hundred pages (cut down from nearly eight hundred in its French-language edition), Olivier Todd’s extensive and vastly readable biography of Albert Camus reflects on this point countless times. Todd manages to present the subject of his investigation, M. Camus, without manipulating him for his own reasons.

He manages to be as honest about Camus as Camus was when explicating the stories of others in his journalistic pieces. Todd’s justification for writing a new biography of Camus rests on the simple fact that time has passed since Herbert Lottman’s extensive 1978 biography.

Todd’s writing is hardly dry or analytic in its tone, thanks in large part to the more than two hundred people he interviewed, but it does avoid much of the posthumous legend-making and sensationalism that often accompany the passing of great figures. Neither does Todd couch his views in a particular ideological or academic jargon; his assessment of the man is rounded and understandable throughout.

While dealing with the life of Camus chronologically, Todd pinpoints certain recurring themes, such as: the life and pursuit of Camus’ boyhood academic dreams, as sparked by his philosophy instructor and friend, Jean Grenier; Camus’ identification of joie de vivre and passion with the Algerian coast and sun; his lifelong dedication to the dramatic theater; his Epicurean tendencies when it came to physical health and desire; liberty and its relationship to the Absurd; and Camus’ thoughts on the possibility of loving another human being.

As Todd shows, Albert Camus dramatized the condition of the modern person where his philosophical confrère, Jean-Paul Sartre, with a few exceptions, only theorized it. Camus’ lower-class Algerian upbringing had made experience of abandonment or estrangement in a nonsensical universe real to him; his time as a journalist had fused his theories to the specific dilemmas faced by individuals and governments. A novel such as L’Étranger, while similar in mood and color to Sartre’s La Nausée, reveals a different depth of thought, a more ambiguous depth.

In Camus’ writings, life is not so much at fault for humankind’s dilemmas as is the strange but contingent mixture of man and life itself. When these two principles, or systems, are joined, or at least an attempt to join them is made, confusion ensues and the Absurd is born. Todd notes: “The universe is not absurd in itself, any more than it is yellow or sugary: it simply is. Life and the world have a meaning for the believer who has a code of conduct in the Gospels based on the word of Christ. Camus’ anguish came from the fact that no morality was imposed by an atheist or an agnostic’s world.”

Todd seems most impressed with Camus in the middle section of the biography when he describes him as one who, when faced with the fact of the Absurd, did not try to go at it with a lot of ideological prescriptions. Camus acknowledged that a “better way” was to be had, but that better way could never be applied flawlessly to the lives of all people. Just as we all learned in basic arithmetic, a remainder is often left, something that does not yield an easy “fit” in the system and will not be forced. That this puzzle of sorts would always remain undone was something that, it would seem, Camus understood from an early age.

Todd argues: “Camus was aware of the absurd side of current events, and he shared these with Francine [his second wife]: ‘. . . I don’t think I’m the only person to find all this absurd. On the contrary, I think that it’s a useful view for us all. . . . People say That’s absurd, but then they pay their taxes and put their daughter into a religious school, because they think that there’s nothing else to do, after one has said that things are absurd, whereas in reality, that’s only the beginning. I can’t explain in a few words what would take a whole book to say. . . . Philosophical thought only begins when we challenge the logic of clichés with rigor and honesty.’”

Though the right, or “perfect,” answer is nowhere to be found, for Camus, life was still at hand: life wanting to be lived. Life for Camus did not demand a template of normality. Such templates of belief and blind obedience had been applied in the past and were found both inconsistent and incomplete. As Camus himself noted in the first draft of an insert for his most well-known philosophical essay Le Mythe de Sisyphe, “Modern intelligence suffers from nihilism, and to cure it, we propose that it forget its illness and go backwards. Such are the ‘returns’ to the Middle Ages, to a primitive mentality, to the so-called ‘natural life,’ to religion – in short, to the arsenal of old solutions. But to give a shadow of usefulness to these cures, several centuries’ contributions must be denied; we must pretend to be ignorant of what we know very well, to pretend we have learnt nothing and to efface what is ineffaceable. This is impossible.”

Thus, Camus honed the notion of living with doubt to an art form. Life and human existence were “givens” that only man and his imagination could give variations to. For example, the sun that incites Camus’ protagonist, Meursault, in L’Étranger, to kill the Arab is the same sun that helps the plants to grow and the cycles of life to continue. The Absurd . . . at its most beautiful.

Todd argues convincingly that Camus exemplifies the best in the French intellectual tradition of questioning from the perspective of the man and the intellectual. The intellectual could go home from the café at the end of the evening, but the man couldn’t. For him, in his very sinews, the questions continued. The man always was, everywhere and at every time, as cognizant at the breakfast table as in the bed in throes of sexual passion. And always the questions were confronting him. The world and its troubling whispers never went away.

As Todd notes in one chapter’s conclusion, “Like his first-person narrator, Rieux, in La Peste, Camus felt closer to failures than with saints. Rieux affirmed, as Camus might have: ‘I don’t believe I have any taste for heroism or saintliness, what interests me is being a man.’” Need anything more be said?

Chris Voigt