Sorry, Time's Up!
Wakefulness, by John Ashbery (Knopf)
As he makes so clear in Wakefulness, the first and title poem of his newest volume, John Ashbery has a lover’s quarrel with the presence of time and the limitations it places on our creativity. The anxiety of passing time — Look, there it goes… you missed it! — however, provides the rich fodder for Ashbery’s complex meditations and the subsequent evolution of his poetics. For time, like life itself, is upon us and without our consent. No matter what we choose to do, short of putting a gun in our mouth, the show must go on. Like a moving carnival, a feast or circus translated from place to place, time to time, climate to climate, the spectacle of life sweeps each vagrant one of us into its thrall and deposits us glacier-like where fortune sees fit. All takes place in time and, as humans, the March Hare’s dilemma is a universal one.
In the same instant, Wakefulness speaks to us of passages and roads: pilgrimages, the rail journey, heaven, purgatory, and hell, the morning commute, the movement of Hegel’s Zeitgeist. What are we to do? Opening Ashbery’s book, we find that the going-ticket is already in the palm of our hand. All aboard!
The shock of the conductor’s voice, as demanding as an alarm clock’s shrill, is at the heart of this beautiful and disturbing piece of work. Poems that appear unfinished are like the polished cliffs of islands ripped from the main. They’ve been set out in gallery after gallery on the printed page for all to see and shiver at. Ashbery’s title has two meanings: in one sense, wakefulness is a virtue, a beautiful concept out of the more Eastern rivulets of spiritual thought; in another sense, it is an admonition delivered by a Puritan forebear, and is thus connected to a whole other constellation of religious and moral solution-making.
We wake to see the sun outside our window, the impatient atom, the smog-obscured gate of the internment camp, the smile of a small child. It seems that most of the poems in this volume are confrontations, somewhat embattled rendezvous between humans and the pressures, read “truths,” of life. There are demands, as in the poem Tangled Star:
You are come to see us this evening, in the confusion of evening, to test our reflexes, to speak to the dressmaker’s dummy, and derive of it what comfort you can. Your horoscope says so or later, when the voices say: It is important to respect our situation.
In all this, Ashbery pinpoints the seeming democracy of our inner lives. We are all of us children of certain confusion when it comes to the question of how to live this thing called Life.
In another poem, entitled Tropical Sex, Ashbery asks if humans are up against some sort of cosmic aggression. The tone is that of Thomas Hardy and the notion that the universe is governed by the strange minds of a disingenuous vegetable. Who and what’s against us, intent on our destruction? Aliens, God, the late Joan Crawford? Is Being itself angry at humans for their presumption of superiority? Ashbery writes:
I can see thistles out of the corners of my eyes. It must be we are waiting on another’s aggression, handmaidens to the very plot that would destroy us. We can manage a giggle or handshake, but in the end the ink seeps through and the person who did this wants very much to believe it, has put himself inside us for this purpose.
How can one not take this as an ounce of malevolence on the part of a powerful being? It would seem that we unknowingly participate in our plan of our own demise, each of us an Oedipus, each an Electra gone out too far on a limb.
The poem The Friend at Midnight, one of the collection’s finest pieces, couches a criticism of our hubris, or pride, in its description of a valedictorian delivering his commencement address. While the honored man (a persona each of us has taken on at some point or another in our lives) expounds on “Keeping in mind that all things break… Don’t give up,” the poem’s alternative commentator cuts in with Nature’s response and his own: “As he was speaking, the sun set. The grove grew silent. There are more of us taking ourselves seriously now than ever, one thought. We may never realize about our lives till it’s too late, and a man with a dog comes to shoot us.”
The poem is asking: What exactly is our significance? Do we lack the virtue of humility in our lives? Lack wakefulness? Lack stillness, like the grove and the sun that knows when it’s supposed to set? Can we not take ourselves lightly like the clouds in highest heaven? Sadly, as the speaker of The Friend at Midnight notes towards its conclusion, we have little choice in the matter: “Perhaps,” he says, “we will be overtaken even in our happiness, and waves of passion drown us.” It is almost as if in our acquired self-importance, we lose the habit of meekness we possessed when we were little, and thus merit strangely the blows of Time’s Avenger. “The Friend at Midnight become our Judas,” a toxic kiss upon his thin lips.
In The Last Romantic, he writes:
Say, I had a great idea and now it’s gone off and become useless. So may I someday, sitting at play in my little unknown courtyard. So may we all, while cats whine and grapes mature and a prickly dust of unknown origin seems to rise upward from the seats.
This and others of Ashbery’s poems seem to resurrect a notion of the power of rhetoric in poetry — the belief that words can change the world, in their odd mixture of persuasion and perfume. There are occasional riffs of heightened language as if we were hearing a voice out of the King James Version or the Book of Common Prayer. Many of the poems contained in Wakefulness sound like speeches or treatises delivered by the unconscious. When is this not the case with literature? As such, they seem at time without rhyme or reason, vers libre, thoughts trailing off into the night, a multitude of loose ends, and thoughts cut off in mid-flight. Ashbery’s mind is a mind-in-conversation (with itself) — a multitude of senses, identities, and viewpoints that vie with one another beneath the skin for first place. We might ask if ever such a victory is achieved? Ashbery’s conflict of voices reminds one of the T.S. Eliot of Prufrock and The Wasteland where rhetorical statements are arranged in a monumental mosaic of fragments. Whether or not Ashbery has “shored these fragments against my ruin” is not clear yet, as the denouement of peace “Santi, santi, santi” that ends Eliot’s great poem seems left out in favor of a lack of closure. The movie is over, the train has come to a halt, and all there is to announce the “end” is the dust slowly rising from the velvet seats in a haze of light.
Ashbery’s volume can delight us as much as it can dismay us in its complexity. The voice is a fatigued one but one that has seen great things. The persona of many of the poems comes across like a jet-lagged fifth-century B.C. scribe who has just stepped off the flight from Athens to New York. His eyes have been wide-open the entire way. As he says in the first poem, having discovered something, having come to from the whoosh of history:
Here it seems to grow lighter with each passing century. No matter how you twist it, life stays frozen in the headlights.
The journey of life, the migration of the soul, call it what you may. The awareness of our nomad status is burned into our very hides. We are beholden to Time, as Ashbery makes perfectly clear. We view Eden from the last car of a rapidly departing train. A rush of green. Please note apple in foreground.