Brand Voice / Copywriting

Reviews

Book reviews and criticism by Christopher Voigt, writer, editor and creative director.

A Modern Mind

André Gide: A Life in the Present, by Alan Sheridan (Harvard University Press)

As Alan Sheridan tells us in the introduction to his new biography of André Gide: “In that hybrid form, literary biography, the writer must be both literary critic and historian… it is the duty of the literary biographer to delineate the process by which the author transmutes the material of his life into the work, the formal structure of the work, its relation to other works and its reception at the time of publication. But the life, too, has its autonomy… it is part of history and therefore our history.”

It could be said that Gide’s life and the “works of André Gide” are as inseparable as they are seemingly irreconcilable. The life embraced the pressing needs of a readership and, even, a nation; the works encompassed and expanded the modern mind in a way never before experienced. The works offered release and freedom through the everlasting embrace of what Gide called the “fiction,” while he lived his life in constant dialogue with reality and its demands.

The strength of Sheridan’s biography is its relentless attention to Gide the man rather than Gide the novelist. Though Sheridan offers rather informed readings of each of Gide’s works, he goes beyond his call in successfully fleshing out the man-in-the-world. It has been said that Gide’s Journal rests on its hallowed shelf along with Rousseau’s Confessions and Les Mémoires d’outre-tombe of Chateaubriand. Neither Rousseau nor Chateaubriand nor Gide fled from the world he lived in; rather, each ran toward the world with a lusty come-what-may gallop. The confrontation was an occasion for sublimity.

Coming from a conservative, Huguenot Protestant background, the young André Gide had two choices: follow nobly as had the others of his family, or rebel. The second choice was not, however, what one would call an overtly conscious decision. Human life is never such a clean progression of forking paths. Very rare is the moment when a choice presents itself in striking black-and-white. Certainly, the same could be surmised for the young André, a boy with the extraordinary capacity not to judge phenomena immediately. Rather, the young Gide placed himself in the thrall of the phenomena; whether it were to the advances of a strange aunt or a rare specimen in the garden of his family’s country home. After the experience, the boy steps back, recoups, and records the event for future use.

Part of the young Gide’s precocious genius was his ability not to lose any of the things that he experienced. The skill is central to the keeping of a good journal; and, as would later become more evident with The Fruits of the Earth and If It Die …, the composition of a living and enduring work of art.

Young Gide’s choice of rebellion came directly from a primary dedication to the truthful and sincere renderings of life’s manifold richness. Gide’s was never a headstrong willfulness; his rebellion was never for the sake of destruction. André’s choice of rebellion came more naturally: it was the sign of a choice to be honest to the times in which he was moving.

And moving he certainly was. Quite literally. The records of Gide’s numerous trips abroad probably fill as much space in the Pléiade Edition of his Oeuvres Complètes as his many novels. It is in the travels – the distancing of himself in early adulthood from literary Paris and conservative, Protestant family manors – that the new Gide appears. The travels, to North Africa and Mediterranean Italy for the most part, opened up new horizons for Gide. He writes in his Journal of his first glimpses of North Africa in October, 1893: “…the crowd straight out of the Arabian Nights, which came hustling around to seize our luggage! We were at the stage of life when every novelty gives untold delight.”

North Africa would leave Gide, as it has many others who came after him, a different man. It was there as a man of twenty-four that he would discover a spontaneity and joie de vivre that many times back home in France he felt harnessed in by manners and stiff upbringing.

It was also there in the Kasbah that André was initiated into the pleasures of the flesh. For the first time, he could meet with women and men who did not shield themselves from sensuality. Behind a wall, in a space enveloped in the scent of orange blossoms, the sexual act would transport Gide into a world his books were forever to champion. Without hope of heaven, the world was the Garden of Delights: it needed to be approached with reverence and joy.

Not the least of this joy came from the fact that North Africa provided a safe and accepting place for Gide to meet young Arab men and embark on the first of his homosexual adventures, without censure. For nearly his entire life, North Africa was to remain Gide’s picture of Eden.

Most of the impetus for Gide’s early novels came out of the North African experience, which oscillated between points of complete surrender to desire and the necessary practice of restraint. Though Gide was never formally religious (much to the dismay of his neo-Thomist friends Claudel, Jammes, and Maritain), his mind was that of a Classical moralist. He had read his Plato and his Aristotle with as much zeal as he had read his Theocritus and his Virgil, and he grappled with the minds of these great men on the issues of sexuality and love. He himself tried very hard – and with good skill – to separate love from the more fleeting demands of the libido. (Sheridan meditates at length on how Gide was able to reconcile a marriage to his cousin Madeleine Rondeaux along with his true, first desire for men.)

Gide understood the pitfalls of desire and tried to navigate them accordingly. This is not to say that he did not fall from time to time. He admitted he was as weak as the next person. What sets Gide’s desires apart, however, from those of many other homosexual artists of his generation was his focus on the act of being with another person, instead of the mere cold contemplation of beauty in another. One reads accounts of Oscar Wilde and Lord Alfred Douglas in North Africa paying young Arab boys so that they could merely “watch,” but Gide was never a voyeur. Gide respected the sexual union as something very close to being “sacred,” without using the religious metaphor. For him, it was about connection and sharing. From this stream of desire, then, it was not very far to reach a greater idea of Love as cohesive to the ideal human community.

For many, including Sheridan, Gide was a man of contradictions. Gide himself, when asked about his books being at odds with each other, would respond by saying that “Each of my books turns against those who like the preceding one.” Clearly, he was being coy to his questioner, but also, quite honest. Book turned against book just as idea turned off of idea, like billiard balls “playing off” one other on a table. In this, one could say that where literature and the life of the mind were concerned, a debate — even, perhaps, a confrontation — was always taking place. Experiences were manifold and thus could be interpreted from a variety of angles, none of which were faulty. The same mind could react to the same thing in, at least, a few different ways.

In literature as in life, the name of the game was active “engagement.” Gide could never stand for those types of writers who adhered to a cause or system of ideas that corrupted the great chain of question-and-answer of Western intellectual tradition. Art, for him, was a testimony of life lived and a testing-ground for ideas. Art was never inert. It was always fostering a dialogue.

George Painter, in his short 1968 biography of Gide, noted: “Like his great predecessors, Dante, Shakespeare, and Goethe, and his equals in his own century, Proust and Joyce, he has constructed for his readers, in a life-work that is both universal and the consummation of his own epoch, a possible paradise that is unassailable by time and contingency.” I view the matter differently.

Painter’s words may be a tad too eulogistic in their tone and their positing of a “possible paradise… unassailable.” Gide understood that we are all damned to the slow road of improvement over and above the Utopian thoroughfare. Perhaps the greatness of Gide’s achievement lies precisely in its not being “unassailable,” so that those who come after him could continue the debate with a man whose flesh was made of living ideas instead of the dead stuff that so much art, after the death of its artist, is doomed to become.

Chris Voigt