Brand Voice / Copywriting

Reviews

Book reviews and criticism by Christopher Voigt, writer, editor and creative director.

Magic and Music From An Earlier Age

Thomas Mann: Eros and Literature, by Anthony Heilbut (University of California Press)

For the contemporary gay reader of Anthony Heilbut’s Thomas Mann: Eros and Literature, an inevitable question arises: Is the subject of Mann’s brand of homosexuality appropriate, or even of interest, to the present generation? Does the closeted, slow-burn passion of a German intellectual lend itself to the curiosity of late twentieth century queers?

It is easy to scrutinize Mann under the examining lamp of gender- and queer-studies, choosing to scrutinize specimens from his life and fiction, but what is his significance? Reading Death in Venice as a senior in high school, I readily picked up on clues to Mann’s gay status, but I wondered, Were they the details of a gay life that I wanted to construct? Not really. More often than not, the gay eroticism of Thomas Mann’s fiction contributed to a forbidden and tragic formulation in the lives of his characters. I gathered, even at that young age, that it must not have been too different in his own life. As Anthony Heilbut shows, I was not too far off the mark.

The question that Heilbut’s book asks is whether or not the writer, celebrated by earlier generations, deserves to be reassessed by readers today. The creative genius and magical lyricism are recognized and lauded, but not without some digging in the basement of desire. In his introduction, Heilbut limns the picture of Mann that existed in the minds of many Germans during his lifetime: the conservative old man (dark suit, small trimmed mustache, the exquisitely knotted tie) at peace in the realm of his mind; the father-figure of the modern German novel.

However, as Heilbut notes: “Matters have changed, at least in Germany, since the publication of his diaries . . . They enable us to see him more precisely as a great erotic writer, a man whose language was saturated by his sexuality.” Indeed, one does not have to look far in a short story or novel of Mann’s to notice this. Beauty and the longing for it are central to the oeuvre of this writer.

Mann and nearly all his characters ache for the experience, and ultimate possession, of the beautiful. Heilbut, time and again in his study, draws attention to the German word Sehnsucht (inadequately rendered as sensual longing). Mann’s characters long for a completion of themselves in the possession and ravishment of a beautiful body (usually that of a handsome young man). Tonio Kröger longs for the blond hair and broad shoulders of his schoolmate love, Hans Hansen, while a much older Aschenbach longs for the classical Hermes-like beauty of the young Tadzio. In both cases, however, the one longed for is never attained; and here is where the problem begins for the contemporary gay reader.

Why is there never a successful attainment? It seems that the failure to fulfill the relationship comes from where Mann chooses to place himself within his text. In Death in Venice, he presents himself as a voyeuristic old dandy brought to an unfortunate demise by his forbidden love. In Tonio Kröger, he chooses to place himself in the position of Tonio: attracted to the masculine erotic but fatalistically kept from it because of his over-developed aesthetic sense.

The two stories, so representative of Mann’s artistic career, encode notions of fatal uniqueness in their main characters. In both, the South (representing the Mediterranean, Munich, even the region of the body as opposed to that of the mind) acts as a symbol of spontaneous eroticism but also as a mark of minority status within a blond-haired, blue-eyed German culture. Tonio’s name and olive complexion and Venice’s romantic but unhealthy atmosphere typify the difference. Heilbut notes that the South, though fulfilling certain physical and aesthetic needs in German artists like Goethe and Mann, possessed an “allure . . . potentially fatal.” Aschenbach is never the same after he lets himself slip into the Venetian cholera epidemic while gazing at Tadzio on the lido. Heilbut sees Mann as one of the primary literary influences on the association in gay men of eros with disease and, eventually, demise (an association, unfortunately, exacerbated by the AIDS epidemic). Mann’s fiction entwines Eros and Thanatos like two serpents staring at each other on a caduceus. Their separation seems impossible.

Heilbut goes to great lengths to draw a believable portrait of the young Mann. He gives attention to Mann’s early infatuations with male students; in particular, his infatuation with Armin Martens, the inspiration for Hans Hansen in Tonio Kröger. Mentioning an entry of Mann’s in the keepsake album of Ilse Martens (Armin’s sister), Heilbut notes that like his alter ego, Tonio Kröger, “he compared himself to Hamlet, crippled by an excess of ratiocination. He also identified himself with both Faust and Mephistopheles, a rich prediction of his later work.”

Heilbut gives superb readings of Mann’s Buddenbrooks, Doctor Faustus, The Magic Mountain, and Joseph and His Brothers. In each, the reader is given the strands of many similar threads: the aristocratic family in decay, the imposed flight into an exotic or foreign territory, the birth of the creative geist from countless limitations.

In each of Heilbut’s readings, he finds a novelist trying desperately to express the feelings within himself, feelings not shared by the heterosexual majority, while simultaneously trying to forge them into something aesthetically pleasing. At one point, Heilbut pictures Mann reading at a podium, “making love to a roomful of faces while maintaining the physical and professional distance that made his work seem immune to autobiographical interpretation.” Thus Mann’s fiction draws a bridge between the spheres of the plainly erotic and the literary. Mann’s books were able to hold their own precisely because they were able to hold this opposition in playful tension. The erotic conflict inspires the words while providing the rules for how it will be represented in fiction.

The best metaphor for working within the erotic conflict, which Heilbut underlines, is that of music. The music of Wagner, in particular, taught Mann valuable lessons about fiction and the feelings that it evokes in the reader. Reading a novel, poem, or short story was for Mann a sensual experience, much like listening to a symphony or an opera. The aesthetic experience born of music was precisely that of energy generated within parameters — just eight notes to work with, as Stravinsky put it. Mann’s writing took on this musical quality — through its division of plots into chapters resembling the movements of a symphony and the use of leitmotif. The erotic tension inherent in music was transported into the pages of a book, a life held between two covers. Writing of Buddenbrooks, Heilbut notes: “In the last passages harmonic resolution is almost impeded by a sustained dissonance, and delirious virtuosity is examined as a pathological symptom. Among other things, Mann was composing the transition from Wagner and Nietzsche to Schönberg and Freud.”

The best of Mann’s characters have musical qualities to them. They are protean — filled with ambiguities — and colorful. They are able to modulate themselves into newer, higher keys, always challenging the limits of plot and character development (for example, Hans Castorp, Felix Krull, even Joseph). To answer the questions with which I began: No, Mann is hardly the role model of healthy sexuality for the current generation. However, his fiction takes chances that he would have never dreamed of taking in his life. It embodies a playful eros that does not fear the donning of a costume or a mask for the sake of the sublime effect. It is to this Mann that Anthony Heilbut pays a worthy tribute with his studied and provocative book.

Chris Voigt