Brand Voice / Copywriting

Reviews

Book reviews and criticism by Christopher Voigt, writer, editor and creative director.

Mirror, Mirror: A Conversation with Daniel Mendelsohn

An interview with Daniel Mendelsohn, author of The Elusive Embrace: Desire and the Riddle of Identity (Knopf)

What can mystify us more than ourselves? Whether we are marveling at the line that comes forth from our outstretched arm as we touch charcoal to canvas or the arpeggio of speech that rises from our mouth, the crux of the situation is a mystery. Why do we create something where previously there was nothing? Why do we make an effort in the way of making something?

Some have said it’s the pursuit of pleasure, others the pursuit of immortality. But these two “needs” can probably be taken care of in a single act that takes all of about 15 minutes, almost anywhere! It must be something else driving us to create, perhaps a need to see those things that can come out of us and yet resemble something not so ethereal as speech. The creation of culture is such a project; for it is as enduring as stone and as enchanting as flesh.

Creating culture mystifies us about as much as the face that greets us in the mirror each morning. Culture reminds us that as much as we are members of a civilization, we cannot be without exerting some of our personality. More than the Who’s-the-Fairest-of-Them-All syndrome would attest, mirror-gazing is an attempt at introspection and, as Daniel Mendelsohn shows in The Elusive Embrace: Desire and the Riddle of Identity (Knopf, $24), not simply a modern one. Just as we create something today, so those who come after us will scrutinize it. They will mine the creation not just for the artist but for some lost fragment of themselves.

Mendelsohn has mined the great myths of our Greco-Roman heritage as well as some of his own: the stories and secrets of a Jewish family and its flight from the Old World, the childhood in a Long Island suburban hamlet, his own flight to the South and the discovery it presaged, the journey into manhood (and fatherhood). As mystifying as any foray into the life of an individual, Daniel Mendelsohn’s mystery is limned with a finesse and a style that will set it apart for years to come.

Early in May, Daniel and I sat and discussed his latest work over coffee and cigarettes. Excerpts of our conversation follow:

Christopher Voigt: I want to start by asking you to flesh out the seemingly conjoined concepts of love and affliction. These two seem to be quite prevalent in most of the Classical sources you cite in your book.

Daniel Mendelsohn: Well, I think, as I talk about in the book, there are these two threads that I am always interested in weaving together. There is, one, the Greek stuff which is very crucial to how I think about things in general; and then, there is just thinking about my life and just generally, the state of being a gay person at this particular junction in history. Then, I’m just interested in the way they come together. I’m writing about or thinking about how gay men go about their emotional and erotic lives and how gay culture — whatever that means — fosters certain ways of thinking about emotional and erotic life… Certainly, when I talk about Love As an Affliction in the book, I’m thinking of certain of my experiences as well as the experiences of most men making their initial introduction into the world of love and desire. This intro is a troubled one because being gay is not the norm… If I were in high school and I said to the School Assembly, “By the way, I want everyone to know that I am gay,” I would have been killed. I would have been taken out in the back everyday and had the living shit beat out of me. And that certainly still goes on, and I don’t want to suggest that it doesn’t, but in a lot of places, it’s a lot easier. Kids are much cooler. So for people of my generation, people now in their late-30s, coming out and experiencing desire and identifying — you know there’s this crucial moment when you know it’s men that you like — is a very troubled moment. And I think I say in the book, for every gay man of my generation, the first love is always traumatic, because it’s someone you feel you’re not supposed to be in love with… And that made me think inevitably of this Greek thing; that if you catalogue the way desire is figured in Greek literature, you know, overwhelmingly, it’s always difficult.

CV: And then, I guess, in our era we have had the added complication of the AIDS epidemic to this original idea of affliction. For you, growing up in a different era, this was not a subject or a fear. It didn’t exist. When I was in my adolescence, this was even a stronger way of perceiving love as an affliction. Love said: If you do it, you will die!

DM: So affliction in love was literalized. You know, I’m in an interesting position chronologically because I was 21 in 1981, which is the first moment of the AIDS crisis, so I’m the sort of exact generation of people to come of age as sexual beings in adolescence, immediately before the AIDS crisis; and yet, to be a young man sexually alert and sexually aware and sexually active immediately on the other side of the chronological fence… When I was 18, love was only a metaphorical affliction, as it were. If I were 18 now, it would be a whole other thing.

CV: You mention in your book an episode on Eighth Avenue where you cruised a young guy who had disguised his K-legions with pancake and subsequently had sex with him. Your last line is very telling of the age you were living in: “We played very safely.”

DM: Well, you have to — it’s unavoidable — but I still think you can be a desiring subject in the scene. You will be confronted with AIDS but it doesn’t have to put an end to desire and sex if you’re smart about it.

CV: I was interested in discussing the polarities of the worlds you discuss in your book. I mean, there’s the Greek world, the Long Island world of fabricated villages and Jewish culture, the Southern world of your sexual awakening at the University of Virginia. It got me thinking about the worlds in which you’ve imaged your sexual coming-of-age, along with this picture of the South which is almost antebellum in its excess and in your highly romanticized way of looking back at your days at the University. I think that all gay men have had their time in this magical world when our souls are just coming into their own. It is a time that in retrospect, I believe, we make emblematic.

DM: A lot of us go to places because we have an image of what those places are supposed to be like, and we will continue to project those images long after we’ve been to them, whether the places can sustain that or not. My decision to go to the University of Virginia for my undergraduate education was a very self-conscious attempt to distance myself from the place where I grew up, in a little town in Nassau County called Old Bethpage, which was the artificial creation of a developer. Long Island was just potato fields that were leveled and then had houses built on top of them. And the thing that I “love” about Old Bethpage is that it’s newer than Bethpage. Bethpage actually goes back to, I think, the seventeenth century, and the developers of this little adjunct “Old” Bethpage gave it such a name to reassure the insecurities of the first-generation Italians and Jews that lived there. So, that was a place. But for someone who grew up in a family where there were lots of stories, a family that was largely connected to another continent, who were only here for a single generation when I was born, I was overloaded with a sense of history that could not find its proper geographical location. My ancestors had been driven out of the original place where their history “took place.” So Long Island was always dissatisfying to me, if only because it felt fake. So I wanted to go to a place where people’s histories were rooted geographically, and that’s why I wanted to go to the South; because, for me, the South was a place where people had lived and where their family mythologies still clung to a town or a plantation. They were still in the place where those histories came from. So my sense of Virginia was colored by my sense of what I hoped it would be. And in a lot of ways, it was that way.

CV: And in a lot of ways, it became that way.

DM: Yes, you see what you are looking for.

CV: The reason I stress so much with you these imaginary places is that I believe all peoples, particularly those who see themselves in some way different than the majority of human beings, value and cherish such places because they stand for some sort of mental or even psychic autonomy. No one can steal that region away from us.

DM: Right. That’s why I go to such great lengths in the first chapter of the book, called “Geographies” to get at this idea of marking out a space that is yours. And that’s why I talk about the place where I came from and also the place I went to: the first of the places that I went to and also the place that I’m haunted by, the old Central European place that my ancestors had to leave. And, there’s this sort of constant ongoing analogy in the book, implicitly between the experience of my family and their history and being forced out of the place where they came from and their having to find a new place and gay people who are often forced out of the places where they grew up to new places where they, in turn, establish a “colony.” For example, I prefer to call Chelsea a “colony” rather than, say, a ghetto. But, whatever you call it, it’s the place that those boys have created to be their place, and it is, in a sense, enriched by projected fantasies as the South was for me. So place is — in the exploration of what identity means — an extremely important notion. Where you decide to be says a lot about you, and for that reason, Chelsea is a very interesting place to think about because it is a “construct.” It’s a projection of a group wish, because as you grow up gay — and you are essentially an oppressed person — you fantasize about the place where everyone is gay and you can just be whatever you are. Chelsea is one of those places — a blank slate that was colonized, so it looks like a gay place. It’s like totally through the looking-glass.

CV: You can go all over the world and find these gay places. What annoys me is that they all look like mirror-images of one another, so that Chelsea and Le Marais and the gay quarters of Amsterdam, Barcelona, Sydney, etc., all sort of share this common sensibility.

DM: Right, except that I would take issue with that only on the grounds that inasmuch as they all look the same, it has been because they have all been colonized by an American gay sensibility. This is because it would seem that the problem of identity is a peculiarly American problem, because we are, as a country, a blank slate colonized by people who wanted to project a fantasy of home onto fresh ground. In a lot of ways, I think my book is about an American problem: How do I know who you are when you’ve left everything behind that constituted you at one point and want to recreate it as a kind of paradisical image of where you should be? In my limited experience, European gay culture is quite different because people are not quite as vexed in the issue of identity as we are. French people know who they are or at least they have some idea of what the French ought to be like. I think Americans are much more troubled because how you should behave — on the whole — changes regionally, changes because of your ethnicity, changes according to your color, etc.

CV: Can you explain — in the light of these dualisms of which we have been speaking — your idea of the “riddle” we have to live with as Americans or as gay Americans.

DM: I think the question of “Who am I?”, though important for all people in all cultures at all times, is especially complex and interesting for Americans, and precisely because there are so many possibilities available to one. I think one of the reasons consumer culture is so strong in the United States is because we are always looking for ways to identify ourselves. So consumer culture offers one the option of “Well, I am what I buy!” This is why advertising was invented in America. Fads. Cloning. All distinctly American phenomena because we’re trying to figure out who we are. Label-consciousness is a symptom of our mass identity-crisis.

CV: Do you think you can go on from this to how people conceive of their sexual roles as a type of identity?

DM: Sure. I think that’s absolutely true. I think that the energy invested in labeling oneself as a sexual actor that you see in middle-class gay culture — you know, what you like, all of the paraphernalia that goes with it: tops, bottoms, leather, this, that, whatever it is, and I have no interest in judging any of it — is somehow different from what you see in straight culture because for straights these things are no longer at the level of consciousness. They’re already available to straight people through mass-culture: dad goes to work, mom stays home with the kid, he drives, she knows how to hang curtains, etc. All of these things have been previously “institutionalized” for straights. Thus role-playing for gays is just a response to what already exists in straight culture in a “natural” way.

CV: Can you discuss a little bit on your concept of identity precisely as it applies to your memories of your father and your own place as a foster-father in the life of the boy you discuss in the book. I was particularly struck by one passage in the book, where you are building a desk in your apartment and you catch a glimpse of yourself in a mirror, and for a split-second you see your father’s body in your own. The mirror then, as it reflects us and images of us, is as important now as it was when Narcissus couldn’t quite move his gaze off his own image.

DM: The easiest way to identify yourself is to see what you look like. In my book, mirrors figure importantly at central moments. Sort of the crucial moment of the book is when I look into the mirror as a nine-year-old and, suddenly, the first-person shifts to the third-person. In the mirror, the “I” becomes a “He.” It’s that person over there. It splits you. And so the mirror is, first of all, another mode of thinking about identity.

CV: It’s also the medium between two different worlds, different times, even different ages of ourselves.

DM: And I think that in that section I am thinking about whom I am as a child, and then it introduces the section on my father and grandfather, my two competing father figures. This in turn becomes a very important issue for me because of my role in the upbringing of the boy, Nicholas, whom I discuss in the book. It made me think about identity temporally, chronologically, and vertically through time. I think in gay culture — and this is a gross generalization — gay men tend to think of themselves traditionally in relation to their mothers rather than their fathers. This is a cultural cliché of some weight. And so I thought it would be more interesting for the book to think about fathers. Fathers and sons are very important to me also because of the Greek stuff. In Greek culture, your only identity is through your father’s side. Greeks don’t care about the mother. You’re the “son of… “ And, since now I am in this quasi-paternal role with this child, my relationship with my own father becomes even more important to me. The father question also becomes quite important when I ask myself the question “Who am I?” and the answer turns out to be: “I’m a man.” So I thought for that reason it would be more interesting to explore the father relationship.

Just parenthetically, I can only think of one instance in Classical Greek literature where mirrors play a central role. It’s in the Medea, in a section where Euripides describes the woman for whom Medea’s husband has dumped her. Medea gives her victim a poison crown and in the climactic scene the girl dies while admiring herself crowned in a mirror.

So maybe mirrors are also an affliction… in Greek literature, that is.

Chris Voigt